Analysis of the Care Quality Commission (CQC)’s State of Care Report for 2022/23

Feb 19, 2024 | Priorities

The Care Quality Commission (CQC)’s State of Care Report for 2022/23 offers an in-depth look at England’s health and social care system, revealing significant insights into access, quality, workforce, and systemic issues. This adaptation incorporates more statistics and comparisons with previous reports to provide a clearer picture of the evolving challenges and achievements within the sector.

  • Access to Care: The enduring challenge of accessing care services is underscored by the statistic that over 7 million people were on elective care waiting lists by June 2023, a record high that reflects an increasing demand for services. This figure represents a significant increase from previous years, indicating a growing backlog of care needs. The difficulty in securing GP and dental appointments has led to an over-reliance on urgent and emergency care services, with more than half (51%) of respondents reporting waits of over an hour for examination in urgent care settings in 2022, up from 28% in 2020.
  • Quality of Care: The report finds that while the overall quality of care remains satisfactory, with 79% of adult social care providers rated as good in 2023, this figure has remained relatively stable from 2022, suggesting a plateau in quality improvements. Staffing pressures have been highlighted as a significant factor affecting service quality, with mental health and wellbeing of staff directly impacting their ability to deliver safe, high-quality care.
  • Inequalities: The report continues to highlight inequalities in health and social care, noting that individuals from ethnic minority groups and those with protected equality characteristics face significant barriers in accessing and receiving quality care. These challenges are compounded by systemic issues such as racial stereotypes, discrimination, and a lack of cultural competency among care providers.
  • Workforce: The sector faces critical workforce challenges, with reports of over 50% of adult social care providers struggling with recruitment and 31% facing retention issues. Despite a decrease in care home staff vacancy rates from 11% in the first quarter of 2022 to 7% in the second quarter of 2023, the overall satisfaction with pay among NHS staff has fallen by 12 percentage points since before the pandemic, with only 26% expressing satisfaction in 2023. Furthermore, the number of overseas staff arriving to work in the care sector increased to 70,000 in 2022/23, up from 20,000 in the previous year, highlighting the sector’s growing reliance on international recruitment to fill staffing gaps.
  • Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (DoLS): The system faces ongoing challenges, with applications to deprive individuals of their liberty rising to over 300,000 in 2022/23. However, only 19% of these applications were completed within the statutory 21-day timeframe, a statistic that underscores the systemic delays and inefficiencies in protecting vulnerable individuals’ rights.
  • Systems: The introduction of new integrated care systems aimed at improving coordination and addressing disparities has been a key development. Yet, the effectiveness of these systems in enhancing urgent and emergency care services and addressing unwarranted variations in health outcomes remains to be fully realized, as indicated by ongoing poor experiences in urgent care and a need for a systemic response to workforce and access issues.

This year’s report illustrates a healthcare sector at a crossroads, with significant challenges in access, quality, and workforce sustainability, alongside systemic inequalities that persist despite efforts to address them. The statistics from the 2022/23 report, in comparison with previous years, highlight the need for continued focus on improvement, innovation, and systemic change to meet the evolving needs of England’s population.

Considering this for your Consultant Interview

In light of the Care Quality Commission (CQC)’s State of Care Report for 2022/23, as you prepare for your consultant interview, it’s essential to equip yourself with insights that reflect your understanding of the current healthcare challenges and your readiness to address them. Here’s how you can approach potential questions:

  1. Regarding the challenge of access to care, including increased waiting times and access difficulties, how would you improve access in your specialty?
    • This question probes your awareness of systemic healthcare issues and your strategic thinking around solutions. Consider discussing innovative approaches to service redesign, the implementation of efficient patient triage systems, or leveraging technology to enhance access. Your answer should reflect a deep understanding of the issue and a clear vision for mitigating it.
  2. Inequalities in health and social care are significant concerns. What strategies would you employ to address these within your practice?
    • This asks for your insight into tackling health inequalities, a critical issue highlighted in the report. Reflect on how you would implement initiatives that foster equity, such as cultural competency training for your team, targeted outreach efforts, or services designed to be more inclusive. Highlight your commitment to ensuring equitable care for all patients, showcasing your proactive stance on creating a more inclusive healthcare environment.
  3. Given the staffing challenges and concerns over workforce wellbeing identified in the report, how would you support and retain your team?
    • This question assesses your leadership qualities and your approach to managing a team under the reported conditions of dissatisfaction and high turnover. Discuss your strategies for promoting staff wellbeing, such as introducing regular wellness check-ins, offering professional development opportunities, and creating initiatives aimed at improving job satisfaction and work-life balance. Your response should illustrate a leadership style that prioritizes the health and happiness of your team, ensuring a supportive and motivating work environment.

In preparing your responses, focus on conveying a comprehensive understanding of the healthcare landscape, as detailed in the CQC’s report. Demonstrate your ability to apply this knowledge towards effective solutions and leadership strategies. By doing so, you’ll not only show your readiness for the consultant role but also your commitment to advancing healthcare quality and accessibility.

Download the CQC Report State of Care Report for 2022/23

Written by Andrew Vincent

Written by Andrew Vincent

Co-founder and Lead Coach for Consultant Interviews. Co-author of The Consultant Interview (Oxford University Press). Director of a respected healthcare provider. Appointed dozens. Rejected more. Coached multiple hundreds.